Four deterministic-script defects plus a contract gap, all reported by a
downstream KB running 1.11.0. None of them crashed; each produced confident,
wrong output, which is why they went unnoticed.
retrieve_candidates.py:
- load_pages() walked rglob unsorted, so tests/expected/retrieve.json encoded
one machine's directory order and the smoke test failed on a clean clone.
- cited_by used setdefault, crediting a shared source to whichever page was
walked first and dropping the source from the results entirely, so the other
citing pages reported corroborated_by: []. Now every citing page is credited.
lint_report.py:
- check 12 reported a cited directory as "does not exist", because is_file()
is false for a directory. Citing a subtree is now explicitly legal and
carries no fingerprint; same fix in lint_quick.sh and lint_quick.ps1.
- check 8 keyed log entries on timestamp + file with the action type dropped,
so a Rule B POINTER was indistinguishable from a duplicate of the entry it
points at. POINTER is now exempt; genuine duplicates still fire.
- check 13 required a backticked path, so "— Chat conversation, Name, date"
counted as unattributed although AGENTS.md lists it as a first-class source.
Attribution and verifiability are now separate questions.
AGENTS.md documents both resolved contract gaps: directory citations, and the
two legal attribution shapes. The fixture KB gained coverage for all three lint
defects — each finding fires under the old script and is silent under the new.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>